Sunday, March 21, 2010

Editorial #3

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/03/opinion/03wed4.html

The name of this editorial is "Fighting Chance" and it was published in the NY times on March 2, 2010. It talks about how the populations of sage grouse has dropped from 16 million to a few hundred thousand that are only scattered in about 11 western states so they are trying to figure out ways to preserve them. They are also talking about if they should put this bird on the endangered species list soon. The problem is that the mandated protections could seriously inhibit coal mining, oil and gas exploration and other businesses vital to Western economies and it could also slow the development of wind power. They are talking about a compromise solution, which would give the grouse a fighting chance and it would be better for the western industry. They would place the sage grouse high on its list of 270 or so “candidate species.” That acknowledges that the species is in trouble, asks federal and state land management agencies to work harder to protect the bird’s habitat. They would design core areas for the grouse to live, so they wouldn't be harmed.
These are useful first steps, but they say that in a landscape already full of threats to the grouse, including grazing, a lot more will be needed to ensure the bird’s survival at robust levels.

I don't know how I feel about this article, you could argue both ways. I understand that they need to try to preserve the birds because the numbers are dropping quickly. But at the same time, putting them on the endangered species list would inhibit the coal mining, oil, and gas exploration which we really need to take advantage of that right now. Because we are in a recession, maybe if they found more sources of this then the prices would be cheaper because we wouldn't have to export as much. Also the western united states needs the money from finding those new mines and stuff, because thats some peoples jobs so that wouldnt be helping them. I understand we do need to preserve these birds because we don't want them all to die out, but there needs to be another solution to help with both sides. Maybe they can try putting them in a new habitat where they wouldn't have all of these threats.. hmm who knows, hopefully they figure something out that will benefit both parties.

No comments:

Post a Comment